Public Comment on NIH Workshop on Monkey Research

  • Home
  • About
  • Books & Articles
    • Phoenix Zones
    • Articles & More
  • News & Events
  • Contact

Public Comment on NIH Workshop on Monkey Research

September 9, 2016 by Hope Ferdowsian

Human and Animal Research Ethics

Earlier this week, the National Institutes of Health hosted a conference on the use of nonhuman primates in research. The workshop was the subject of considerable controversy.

Here are the public comments I submitted in advance of the workshop:

As Dr. John Gluck points out in his recent Opinion Editorial in The New York Times, in 1974, a federal commission was formed to develop ethical principles for human research. In contrast, no similar, comprehensive and principled effort has addressed the use of animals in research – despite the large body of science showing how animals can suffer physically and mentally. To address this gap, Dr. Gluck, Dr. Tom Beauchamp, many other colleagues, and I worked on a multi-disciplinary National Science Foundation grant exploring the limits of existing animal research guidelines, as well as potential solutions. Results were reported in multiple publications, including a special issue of Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics called Rethinking the Ethics of Research Involving Nonhuman Animals. One of the articles, authored by primatologist Dr. Agustin Fuentes and myself, addressed the imbalance between the harms of research involving nonhuman primates and deprivation of benefits to them. We concluded much of the laboratory research conducted today has inadequate standards, leading to significant physical, psychological, and social harms to nonhuman primates. Several other articles in the series examine how widely recognized bioethical principles could better inform decisions about the use of animals, including nonhuman primates, in research.  I urge you to consider factors such as these in your deliberations.

 

More Articles from Hope Ferdowsian

  • How Journalists, Artists & Physicians are Shaping the Healthcare Debate: The “SOME PEOPLE” (Every)Body ExhibitionHow Journalists, Artists & Physicians are Shaping the Healthcare Debate: The “SOME PEOPLE” (Every)Body Exhibition
  • Sexual Violence Is Not Excused by CultureWhat’s the Best Answer to the Assault on Compassion? Moral Courage
  • An Interview with Writer & Publisher Martin RoweAn Interview with Writer & Publisher Martin Rowe
  • Dr. Emily Peitzman: Pediatrician & Animal AdvocateDr. Emily Peitzman: Pediatrician & Animal Advocate
  • Finding Meaningful Resolutions in the New YearFinding Meaningful Resolutions in the New Year
  • The High Price of a Torture PolicyThe High Price of a Torture Policy

Filed Under: All Blog Posts, Animal Rights, Medicine and Public Health

Recent Posts

  • A Visit with Brain & Ethics Expert Dr. Syd Johnson June 17, 2020
  • Freedom of Movement in the Wake of Coronavirus March 24, 2020
  • Interview with Mia MacDonald of Brighter Green December 2, 2019

Blogs & Articles Categories

  • All Blog Posts
  • Animal Rights
  • Ethics
  • Human Rights
  • Interviews
  • Medicine and Public Health

Search

Reach Out

    Stay Connected

    Connect!

    Copyright Hope Ferdowsian 2023